Direct write-off vs allowance method.
Two methods exist. Direct write-off: when a specific invoice is confirmed uncollectible, post DR Bad Debt Expense / CR Accounts Receivable. Simple, but it concentrates the expense in the period of recognition rather than the period of sale, which violates the matching principle. Allowance method: estimate doubtful accounts each period and post DR Bad Debt Expense / CR Allowance for Doubtful Accounts. When a specific invoice is later written off, post DR Allowance / CR Accounts Receivable. P&L impact was already taken in the period of sale.
Tax law in most countries allows a deduction only for debts actually written off with evidence that they are uncollectible, not for a general provision. So most SMBs use the allowance method for management accounts and the direct method for tax. Both coexist in the same books, with the difference tracked as a reconciling item.
The actual journal entries.
Allowance creation, period-end estimate of $180,000: DR Bad Debt Expense 180,000 / CR Allowance for Doubtful Accounts 180,000. The allowance shows on the balance sheet as a contra-asset under AR, reducing net AR. When customer X is confirmed dead with a $75,000 balance: DR Allowance for Doubtful Accounts 75,000 / CR Accounts Receivable - Customer X 75,000. No P&L impact, because the expense was already taken via the allowance.
If the customer later pays (rare but happens): DR Cash 75,000 / CR Bad Debt Recovery 75,000 (or CR Allowance, depending on policy). Sales tax adjustment if eligible: DR Output Tax 12,750 / CR Bad Debt Expense or specific GL account. The tax recovery is real cash flow back, do not skip the entry just because it is small.
When a debt qualifies as bad.
For a tax deduction, three conditions are typical. The debt must have been included in income previously (a trade receivable from a sale, yes; a personal loan to a director, no). The debt must actually be written off in the books in the same tax year you claim. The debt must be such that, in the opinion of the taxpayer, no reasonable prospect of recovery exists. The third is subjective but auditors expect evidence: legal notices, customer business closed, traceable absconding, court rejected, agency exhausted.
Rule of thumb for evidence: at least two of the following. (1) Customer business closed (gazette notice or visit confirmation). (2) Customer not reachable for 90+ days despite documented attempts. (3) Legal notice issued under acknowledgment, no response. (4) Court decree against customer with no recovery. (5) Negotiated settlement at less than face value (write off the difference). With this paper trail, the deduction is defensible.
Getting the sales tax back on a bad debt.
When you sell on credit, you charge output tax and remit it on your sales tax return even before the customer pays. If the customer never pays, you have remitted tax on a sale that produced no cash. Many VAT and GST systems allow bad-debt relief once the debt has been overdue for a set period (six months in the UK, for example) and written off in the books; the relief is claimed in the return for the period of the write-off. The conditions vary by country, so check your own before you claim.
A worked example: a $200,000 invoice with 17% sales tax of $34,000, sold on credit in October. The customer absconds and the debt is written off in May, after the waiting period has passed. The return for May reclaims the $34,000 of output tax. Net impact: bad debt expense of $200,000 in the P&L, $34,000 of tax recovered in the return — real cash back to that extent.
Documentation a tax auditor will accept.
For each bad debt write-off, keep a file with the following: the original invoice, the customer aging history showing it was tracked, the dunning trail (emails, WhatsApp, call logs), at least two pieces of evidence of uncollectibility (closure notice, legal letter, agency report, etc.), the journal entry posting the write-off, a board or management resolution approving the write-off if the amount is material, and the sales tax adjustment line in the relevant your sales tax return if claimed.
Without this file, the deduction can be disallowed and a penalty added. With it, the auditor checks one or two and moves on. SMBs that systematically file bad debt evidence at the time of write-off (not when the audit notice arrives) sail through audits. Those that scramble at the last minute often lose the deduction.
- Original invoice and aging history.
- Dunning trail: emails, WhatsApp, calls.
- Two pieces of evidence of uncollectibility.
- Approval of write-off above material threshold.
- The sales tax bad-debt relief claim, if made.
Avoid the common owner mistakes.
Mistake one: writing off because "the customer is difficult." Difficulty is not uncollectibility. Document specific evidence. Mistake two: writing off small amounts without record. $8,000 may seem trivial, but a hundred such write-offs across a year add up to $800,000 of unjustified expense. Mistake three: writing off a related-party balance to manipulate profit. Tax authorities have explicit anti-avoidance rules for related-party transactions.
Mistake four: writing off in the wrong year. Most tax codes require the write-off in the year you claim the deduction. Writing off in March 2026 and claiming in 2025 fails. Mistake five: not telling the customer. Sometimes a written-off customer surprises you with payment. If your AR system shows zero balance and you receive $75,000, post it as bad debt recovery, not a duplicate sale.
Recovery accounting after write-off.
A written-off customer pays $50,000 against an old $200,000 invoice. Three options. Option A (clean P&L): DR Cash 50,000 / CR Bad Debt Recovery 50,000. The recovery hits this period income. Option B (against allowance): DR Cash 50,000 / CR Allowance for Doubtful Accounts 50,000. The allowance is replenished for future write-offs. Option C (reverse and reapply): DR AR Customer X 50,000 / CR Allowance 50,000, then DR Cash / CR AR. Same net effect.
For tax, the recovery is generally taxable income in the year received. If the original write-off was claimed as a deduction, the recovery is income. If the original write-off was disallowed by your tax authority, the recovery is not taxable (no double dip). Track the linkage so you can explain to the auditor.
Closing the loop with credit policy.
Write-offs are the cleanup; the prevention is upstream. Customers who become bad debts are usually visible 90 days before the write-off. Credit limits set at onboarding, enforced at order entry, prevent most of it. Aging reviews catch the rest. A bad debt ratio of more than 1.5% of credit sales is a credit policy problem, not a collection problem.
Set the credit limit, enforce it before goods leave (no new orders for customers over 60 days past due unless a named person signs off), review the aging weekly, escalate per the dunning ladder. With this loop in place, write-offs become rare and predictable. Without it, write-offs are surprise hits to the P&L every quarter.