Read rates are not paid rates.
WhatsApp and SMS messages are usually read within minutes of arriving; a reminder email can sit unopened for days, especially in a busy accounts payable inbox. That is the case for messaging. The case against it is that a read message is not a paid invoice: WhatsApp is easy to read and just as easy to dismiss, while email feels formal, carries the PDF and becomes the record a B2B customer’s AP team works from.
So the answer is not "use WhatsApp" or "use email". It is the right channel for the region, the customer and the stage of the ladder, and a message on every channel that makes paying the easiest next step.
Channel by stage of the dunning ladder.
In a WhatsApp-strong region (Latin America, India, southern Europe, the Middle East, parts of southeast Asia): Stage 1 (1 day past due, friendly nudge): email. Low-stakes, you want it on record, not pushy. Stage 2 (7 days): WhatsApp, where most replies come from. Stage 3 (21 days): both, email for the record and WhatsApp to be read. Stage 4 (45 days): WhatsApp first, email backup. Stage 5 (60 days): email plus a phone call.
In a US or UK B2B-style market: Stage 1: email. Stage 2: email follow-up with a personalised subject line. Stage 3: email plus a phone call. Stage 4: email plus phone, with SMS as an option. Stage 5: formal letter plus phone. WhatsApp is rarely the right channel for B2B accounts payable departments in these markets. SMS plays a useful role in Australia and Northern Europe at stages 2 and 3.
- WhatsApp-strong markets: WhatsApp for stages 2-4, email for the record
- US/UK B2B: email primary, phone for escalation
- Australia / Northern Europe: SMS plays the role WhatsApp plays elsewhere
- Phone for every stage 5 escalation
- Per-customer channel preferences override the defaults
Customer type matters.
B2B corporate customers (banks, multinationals, larger SMBs): email first, regardless of region. Their AP processes run on email, and a WhatsApp or SMS message often reaches the wrong person, a sales contact instead of accounts payable. SMB-to-SMB: WhatsApp first in WhatsApp-dominant regions, email first elsewhere; owner-to-owner conversation is faster on WhatsApp and often reaches the decision-maker directly.
B2C customers (retail credit, service customers): in WhatsApp-strong markets, WhatsApp throughout, with email only for stage 1 and stage 5. In US and UK markets, SMS and email work. The relationship is personal and the amounts are usually smaller. The same business can run different mixes for different customer types and regions.
Tone differences between channels.
WhatsApp and SMS are conversational. Write in the first person ("Hope you are well, just a quick reminder..."), avoid corporate language and keep it short: three or four lines on WhatsApp, under 160 characters for SMS. Include the invoice number and amount but skip the legal language. Email is formal: full sentences, complete reference details, the invoice PDF attached and a signature block. Same content, different presentation.
A common mistake is sending the same template on both channels. The email looks fine, but the WhatsApp version reads like a robot and gets fewer replies. Keep separate templates per stage per channel; writing them once pays off across thousands of messages.
An illustration: a building materials supplier.
Picture a building materials supplier with 400 active trade customers, email-only reminders and a DSO of 58 days. Most of its customers are small contractors who live on WhatsApp and rarely open email during the working day, so the reminders are sent but not read.
Adding a WhatsApp message at stages 2 to 4, with the invoice amount and a way to pay, puts the reminder where the customer actually looks. On R$1.6M of monthly revenue, about R$53,000 of sales a day, every day taken off DSO frees roughly R$53,000 of cash; ten days is over half a million.
When WhatsApp or SMS goes wrong.
Three failure modes. One: too many messages, so the customer mutes or blocks you. Respect the cadence (at most one reminder a week per invoice) and offer an opt-out. Two: messages from a staff member’s personal number, which customers stop trusting. Use a business number. Three: a tone so casual it looks unprofessional. Have the owner review the templates instead of improvising.
A fourth, subtler failure: no clear way to pay. The customer reads the message, means to pay, gets distracted and forgets. Every message should end in a link to the invoice or a clear next step ("reply YES and we will send the bank details"). Friction kills conversion.
What Nonari does.
In Nonari, the scheduled part runs by email: on the due date and at 7, 14 and 30 days overdue, the customer is emailed the amount due with a link to the invoice in the customer portal, and each reminder is recorded against the invoice so the history is visible.
The WhatsApp and SMS stages go out from the invoice itself. WhatsApp opens with the customer’s number and the invoice details already filled in, and you press send from your own business number; SMS is sent from the same screen; and on a phone you can share the invoice PDF directly. The personal stages stay personal, which is where they work best.