POS, inventory and multi-branch on one ledger — every sale posts to stock, cash and the P&L the moment it rings.Why ledger-first →
Accounting · January 29, 2026 · 9 min read

Withholding Tax on Services vs Goods: How It Works on Supplier Payments

In countries that withhold tax on supplier payments, a services invoice and a goods invoice for the same amount can trigger very different deductions. Get it wrong and either you over-withhold and sour a supplier relationship, or you under-withhold and the tax authority comes to you for the difference, plus interest and penalty.

Why withholding tax exists at all.

Withholding tax is a tax authority collecting income tax at source instead of waiting for the recipient to file. Where it applies to domestic payments, the business paying a supplier deducts a percentage from the payment, deposits it with the tax authority and gives the supplier a certificate; the supplier claims the amount as a credit in its own return, and gets a refund if the credit exceeds what it owes. India’s TDS, the Philippines’ expanded withholding tax and the UK’s Construction Industry Scheme all work this way, each with its own rates and scope.

For an SMB the questions are always the same four. Am I required to withhold on this payment? At what rate? Did I deposit and report it on time? Did I give the supplier a certificate? Get those four right and withholding stops being frightening.

Why services and goods carry different rates.

Where a country withholds on both, services usually carry the higher rate. The logic is margin: a supplier of goods passes most of what it is paid on to its own suppliers, while a supplier of services keeps most of it as income, so withholding a larger share of a service fee is closer to the tax the supplier will finally owe. The rates and the special categories (rent, transport, commission, professional fees) come from each country’s own table, so check yours every budget.

The standard mistake is treating a services invoice as a goods invoice. Software development is a service. So are consulting, accounting, legal work, marketing, repair and transport: anything where the deliverable is time or expertise. If the deliverable is a physical thing, it is goods. Classify on substance, not on how the invoice is worded.

Goods · physical deliverableUsually the lower rateSupplier passes most of the price onThreshold per supplier is commonEvidence: delivery note + invoiceServices · time or expertiseUsually the higher rateMost of the fee is the supplier’s incomeThresholds are often lowerEvidence: contract + invoice
Where both are withheld, services usually carry the higher rate, so classifying a service as goods is a common audit finding.
  • Goods: physical deliverable, usually the lower rate.
  • Services: time or expertise, usually the higher rate.
  • Specified categories (rent, transport, commission) often have their own rates.
  • Unregistered payees often face a higher rate.
  • Rates change with budgets: check the current table.

A worked example with two suppliers.

Take illustrative rates of 2% on goods and 10% on services. In May you pay two invoices. Supplier A sells you $500,000 of inventory: withholding at 2% is $10,000, so you pay $490,000, deposit $10,000 with the tax authority and issue a certificate. Supplier B, a consultant, invoices $200,000 for marketing services: withholding at 10% is $20,000, so you pay $180,000, deposit $20,000 and issue the certificate.

In your books: DR Inventory 500,000 / CR Bank 490,000 / CR Withholding Tax Payable 10,000 for supplier A; DR Marketing Expense 200,000 / CR Bank 180,000 / CR Withholding Tax Payable 20,000 for supplier B. When you deposit: DR Withholding Tax Payable 30,000 / CR Bank 30,000. Three balanced entries, two suppliers paid net, the tax authority paid in full.

Supplier B — $200,000 service invoice, 10% withheldDEBITCREDITMarketing expense200,000Bank (paid to supplier)180,000Withholding tax payable20,000TOTAL DR200,000TOTAL CR200,000
The expense is the full invoice. The supplier receives the net amount, and the withheld 10% sits as a liability until it is deposited.

When you do not have to deduct.

Not every payment triggers withholding. Many regimes set a threshold per supplier per year, exempt payments to government bodies and banks, and let a supplier present an exemption or reduced-rate certificate, in which case you withhold at the rate the certificate states. Keep a copy of every certificate with the supplier record.

Where SMBs trip up is the cumulative threshold. Say the threshold is $75,000 a year. You buy $40,000 of stationery from one supplier in July and withhold nothing because you are under it. You buy another $50,000 in November. Cumulative spend is now $90,000, you have crossed the threshold, and depending on the rules you may owe withholding on the November payment and on the earlier one too. Track cumulative spend per supplier.

July $40kUnder $75k, nothing withheldNovember $50kCumulative $90kThreshold crossedWithhold on Nov, maybe July tooIf missedTax, interest and penalty
Thresholds are usually cumulative per supplier per year (here an illustrative $75,000). Track running totals or the crossing month catches you out.

Deposits, statements and certificates.

Withheld tax is usually due to the tax authority by a fixed day of the following month, and reported on a periodic statement listing every payee with their tax ID, the amount paid, the rate and the tax withheld. An annual statement or reconciliation often follows. Deadlines vary by country, so put yours in the close calendar.

The payee needs a certificate or statement to claim the credit. Failing to issue it is usually a separate offence from failing to deposit the tax, and tax authorities enforce both.

How payee status changes the rate.

Many regimes charge a higher rate when the payee is not registered or has not given you a tax ID. The UK’s Construction Industry Scheme deducts 20% from registered subcontractors and 30% from unregistered ones; the US applies 24% backup withholding when a payee does not provide a taxpayer identification number. Other countries publish lists of active taxpayers and charge non-filers a higher rate.

Status is checked on the date of payment, not the date of the invoice. A supplier who was registered when you placed the order may not be when you pay. Check status as part of the payment run, and keep evidence of what you checked.

Withholding tax on payments to non-residents.

Payments abroad are a separate regime. Royalties, technical and consulting fees, and interest paid to non-residents usually attract withholding at a domestic rate, which a tax treaty between the two countries can reduce. To apply the treaty rate you normally need a certificate of tax residence from the recipient before you pay; without it, the domestic rate applies.

A practical example with illustrative rates: $100,000 paid to a consultant abroad for a technical report. The domestic rate on technical fees is 15%; the treaty rate is 10%. Without the residence certificate you withhold $15,000; with it, $10,000. The $5,000 difference on one payment is why you ask for the certificate before paying.

Catching mistakes before the tax authority does.

Three monthly checks prevent most notices. First, the withholding register: every supplier payment in the month, with the rate applied against the rate that should apply. Second, the deposit reconciliation: tax withheld in the books against tax deposited per the payment receipts; the two must be equal. Third, the certificate log: every deduction has a certificate issued on time.

In Nonari, a withholding rate is set up as its own tax code and applied on the document as a deduction from the amount payable, and tax a customer withholds from you is recorded as a withholding receipt against the invoice, so the credit you will claim later is tracked.

Frequently asked

Common questions.

Is my business required to withhold?

It depends on your country’s rules. Companies, government bodies and larger businesses are typically designated as withholding agents, sometimes above a turnover threshold, while small sole traders often are not. Your tax authority’s guidance lists who must withhold and on which payments.

What happens if I deduct withholding tax but forget to deposit it?

In most regimes you become liable for the amount plus interest and penalties, because you held money that belonged to the tax authority. The supplier usually still gets the credit once the tax is deposited. Treat the deposit deadline as fixed.

Can a supplier ask me not to deduct withholding tax?

Only if they hold a valid exemption or reduced-rate certificate from the tax authority. A promise to "pay it myself in my return" does not protect you. Ask for a copy of the certificate, verify it where the authority offers a check, and keep it on file.

How do I treat a mixed invoice of goods and services?

Split the value between goods and services and apply each rate to its part. If the invoice does not split them, ask the supplier for a revised invoice. Tax auditors look at the substance of what was supplied, not at the label on the invoice.

Try nonari

Put your books on autopilot.

Free to start. No credit card. Bring your books, kick the tires, export everything if you decide to leave.